It felt like everyone was starring at me after that question was shouted across the room before class, but that may have just been my perspective. I probably had that deer in the headlights look again, for a good variety of reasons. "Uh, sure...I guess." I suspected that Katie might be interested in me before, but I rarely trusted my own judgment on those issues. I wasn't opposed to the idea, but it took a little getting used to. I had never been on a date, or taken a girl anywhere, so the reality of that imminent situation was foreign (and therefore intimidating) to me.
I don't remember talking with Katie about it at all, but Amanda filled me in on the details of "the plan" later. A bunch of couples were getting a limo together, going out to dinner, and then to the event itself. The good news was that at least half of the ten people in the limo were already friends of mine. Travis, my predecessor as the Manager of Operations in Thunderpaw was still dating Amanda, which is how I knew her. The guy I was preparing to take my place upon graduation was also in our limo, as well as the rest of the junior class officers and their dates.
We stayed at school late for some reason that night, so it was dark as I drove back home with my Mom. She was telling me about how one of her students had come up all excited about their prom plans, with a big limo of people going together, most of whom I knew. "...And then there is Travis & Amanda, and Katie...and she must be going with someone, so there will be ten of them. It sounds like they're going to have a good time together. How come you never do things like that?" "Well, you know the guy Katie's going with, that would be me." My Mom was probably more excited about this than I was.
There was the whole process of getting a tux, and flowers, and everything else. The logistics were amusing. Since the event was put on by the junior class, most of the people in our limo would already be at the venue in Folsom, making the preparations before the event. So our limo was to take us from there, to dinner, and back. The plan was for Katie and I to drive down there with Travis and Amanda, as a double date of sorts, which was just fine with me. I knew both of them much better than Katie, and the group dynamic would be easier to deal with, aka there would be another guy around. (And a much more outgoing one at that, Travis had been our sports commentator as well.)
After the preparations were finished, our group assembled and headed across town to dinner in our limo. Dinner was good, but overpriced and under-portioned. Katie and I talked throughout the evening, but on random surface subjects. I know of nothing significant that I had in common with her. Once we returned, the dance was in full swing, and I remember waiting in line quite a while to get our pictures taken. I never did see any of those photos afterwards, but I would be curious what they looked like.
After that, Katie had to disappear to take care of some of the practical details of hosting the event. I have no idea what she did the rest of the evening, but i hardly saw her. I thought going with a date would prevent me from finding myself standing in the corner alone, but that is what happened. At least I knew the other guys standing around with me, we had been there before. Katie was one of the Prom princesses, and Amanda ended up being selected as the Queen. It would have been pretty amusing if Katie had been selected, the socially inept genius of the school going with the Prom Queen, would clash a bit with the conventional stereotype. Princess was ironic enough as it was. I did eventually dance with her once near the end of the evening. I don't even really like dancing, it just seemed like something we should do, since we went to the dance together.
Once it was over, we went to an after-party of sorts at one of the girls’ houses, who I didn’t know. I don’t recall what went on there besides “not much.” Eventually Travis and Amanda dropped us off where I had left my car, and I drove Katie home. We chatted on the way back, and she invited me inside for a minute, where I met her brother who was still up. It was all pretty anti-climactic, but I was exhausted when I crawled into bed late that night, or early that morning, depending on how you look at it.
I was distraught when I woke up the next morning, but didn’t know why, and definitely couldn’t communicate that to my Mom, who was very concerned and wanted to know what happened. “Nothing, really. I don’t know what’s wrong,” and I didn’t for a long time. At this point I figure that I had expected it to be somehow better to go with a girl, (Otherwise why go to all the trouble?) and it hadn’t been.
The next Monday morning, when I saw Katie in the hallway before class, I said “Hi,” and went up to talk with her. She turned up her nose, turned around, and stormed off. I didn’t have the slightest idea why, and still don’t. She basically never spoke to me again, at least not until after I returned from college. when she was pleasant, but I never asked. That didn’t really improve my opinion of the whole experience.